10 °c
London
Tuesday, April 13, 2021
No Result
View All Result
FurtherAsia FurtherArabia FurtherBrazil FurtherRussia
FurtherAfrica
  • Countries
    • Angola
    • Botswana
    • Cape Verde
    • DRC
    • Eswatini
    • Ethiopia
    • Kenya
    • Malawi
    • Mauritius
    • Mozambique
    • Namibia
    • Nigeria
    • Rwanda
    • South Africa
    • Tanzania
    • Uganda
    • Zambia
    • Zimbabwe
  • OpenTalk
  • Understanding
  • Videos
  • Weekend
  • About
FurtherAfrica
  • Countries
    • Angola
    • Botswana
    • Cape Verde
    • DRC
    • Eswatini
    • Ethiopia
    • Kenya
    • Malawi
    • Mauritius
    • Mozambique
    • Namibia
    • Nigeria
    • Rwanda
    • South Africa
    • Tanzania
    • Uganda
    • Zambia
    • Zimbabwe
  • OpenTalk
  • Understanding
  • Videos
  • Weekend
  • About
No Result
View All Result
FurtherAfrica
No Result
View All Result
Home Africa

Opinion: Mozambique’s debt scandal – Will justice prevail?

Emmanuel Chilamphuma by Emmanuel Chilamphuma
January 17, 2019
in Africa, Banking, Finance, Government, Mozambique, Opinion
Reading Time: 3 mins read
0
Opinion: Mozambique’s debt scandal – Will justice prevail?
Share via QRWhatsappShare on FacebookShare on TwitterLinkedInPinteresteMail

The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York has charged individuals involved in the debt scandal which has troubled Mozambique for several years.

So far, the court has charged three former employees of Credit Suisse, the former minister of Finance of Mozambique, Manuel Chang and a representative of Privinvest, an international shipping company based in Abu Dhabi, over the $2.2 billion loan deal which was supposed to fund three state owned companies.

The loans issued by Credit Suisse and VTB Bank, like any other loan agreement (especially one of this size), should have had strict conditions which the borrower must have met before the loan was approved.
For instance, As I understand, there is a legal cap any government official can approve in terms of sovereign debt without going through parliament and these loans were never brought to the attention of the Mozambican parliament for such approval, which makes a strong case that the entire operation could be rendered unconstitutional. 

Also, the basic fundamentals of due diligence were either poorly conducted or flat out ignored, as all the companies in question did not have any of the necessary financials to contract such loans, yet the bankers went ahead with the loan agreement. In addition, according to a 2017 Kroll audit,  the proposed purpose of the loan did not match the borrowed amount, rendering a quarter of the operation (around US$500m) unaccounted for.

Interestingly, the Mozambique government had a basic understanding with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) that any sovereign borrowing will be kept to a minimum and that the Fund should be informed of any dealings with private banks. The Fund claimed that it was kept out of the loop and that it discovered the deals two years after the loans had been issued. The question that begs to be asked is, if the IMF works very close to the government, often conducting regular audits and economic evaluations (with open access to the government accounts), how is it possible that the IMF resident mission did not notice any of these transactions?

Yet, the IMF and other international donors promptly withdrew financial assistance to the southern African state. This had an impact on the country’s growth as its currency collapsed and until now borrowing from international donors remains restricted.

Although the loans were not directly issued to the government of Mozambique, creditors including Credit Suisse and VTB Bank expect to be repaid. The government has already made an agreement with the lenders to clear the debt using future revenue from LNG projects.  

So far, Credit Suisse has denied any involvement and claims the three former bankers acted alone, out of greed to enrich themselves.

A spokesperson for the bank said, “The indictment alleges that the former employees worked to defeat the bank’s internal controls, acted out of a motive of personal profit and sought to hide these activities from the bank.”

Meanwhile, Mozambicans are the ones stuck with the bill and I for one cannot ignore some of the questions that are not being asked. Such as:

  • Why the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) downgraded the case against Credit Suisse from money-laundering to a regulatory investigation?
  • Are we to believe that Credit Suisse risk did not flag an operation with no adequate due diligence, absenting the bank as a whole of any responsibility?
  • Are we to believe that the IMF went through a good 2 years with a resident mission in country without any suspicious of an operation roughly the size of 20% of the country’s GDP?
  • How is it that no individuals from Russia’s VTB Bank have been indicted or even mentioned up to this point?

I personally respect the caliber of professionals that make the core of institutions like the IMF and Credit Suisse, thus I have a hard time believing in any institutional innocence.

It is increasingly difficult for me to accept that at every financial scandal and government corruption case in Africa, Africans are exclusively to blame. I have no doubt that corrupt Mozambican government officials were at the core of this fraud, however, in my mind, their ability to “deceive”  institutions such as Credit Suisse and the supervision of the IMF is virtually non-existent. 

Corruption is corruption and my faith lies in the American Justice System to bring to light and hold accountable all the villains of this dark episode. I hope justice will reach European financiers and stock listed banks as fiercely as African politicians.  I for one do not think that Mozambicans should suffer any further financial consequences on behalf of these crooks.

Will justice prevail?

Emmanuel Chilamphuma is a Senior Analyst at Edgebold Capital

Related

Tags: Credit SuisseEMATUMEmmanuel Chilamphumahidden debtIMFInternational Monetary FundMAMManny EnyirendaManuel ChangMozambiqueProIndicussovereign debtTuna BondVTBмозамбикموزمبيقモザンビーク莫桑比克
ScanSendShare320Tweet200Share56Pin72Send
Previous Post

Report: How is China securing its LNG needs?

Next Post

Zimbabwe awaits Russian investors

Emmanuel Chilamphuma

Emmanuel Chilamphuma

Emmanuel was born in Zimbabwe to a Malawian family and grew up in London. He holds an International Economic Law degree from the University of London and has been focused in African markets since the beginning of his career. He was previously an Analyst for a UK based family office with assets in Southern Africa. Where he focused on market entry assessments and operational risk.

Related Posts

MTN Group donates US$25M for 7 million vaccine doses for health workers
Finance

MTN values mobile money arm at US$5B, considers IPO

by Staff
April 13, 2021
Angola: AIPEX records over US$3B in private investment
Angola

Angola: AIPEX records over US$3B in private investment

by Staff
April 13, 2021
Total signs agreements with Uganda on East Africa Oil Project
FDI

Total signs agreements with Uganda on East Africa Oil Project

by Staff
April 13, 2021
Mozambique

Mozambique: Gemfields generates first ruby revenue in 15 months

by Club of Mozambique
April 13, 2021
FDI

Total to extend dominance in Africa with go-ahead for Uganda oil

by Staff
April 13, 2021
Next Post
Russia’s VTB says in talks to prolong Angola’s $1.5 billion loan to 10 years

Zimbabwe awaits Russian investors

Namibia government claims Angola Oil not up to standard

Namibia government claims Angola Oil not up to standard

Where Are The Private Equity Buyers In Sub-Saharan Africa Buyer’s Market?

Southern Africa: South Africa backs new Zimbabwe currency

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

2021 AFSIC
2022 Indaba Mining

FurtherAfrica Partners

The Exchange Club of Mozambique Taarifa Rwanda
CrudeMix Africa TechGist Africa Farmers Review Africa
Botswana unplugged Financial Insights Zambia Africa Oil & Power
Harambee Africa Novafrica  

Subscribe to FurtherAfrica

Enter your email address to receive notifications of new articles on your email.

Join 73,051 other subscribers.

FurtherAfrica

© 2021 FurtherMarkets

FurtherAfrica is a FurtherMarkets Limited platform

  • Countries
  • OpenTalk
  • Understanding
  • Videos
  • Weekend
  • About

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Countries
    • Angola
    • Botswana
    • Cape Verde
    • DRC
    • Eswatini
    • Ethiopia
    • Kenya
    • Malawi
    • Mauritius
    • Mozambique
    • Namibia
    • Nigeria
    • Rwanda
    • South Africa
    • Tanzania
    • Uganda
    • Zambia
    • Zimbabwe
  • OpenTalk
  • Understanding
  • Videos
  • Weekend
  • About

© 2021 FurtherMarkets

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?